Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roofing The Pros and Cons of Both
Introduction to Roofing Shingle Options
Most home buyers encounter the decision between installing asphalt shingles or a metal roof when it is time for a full roof replacement.
The roofing material you select determines your home’s exterior design along with its energy efficiency characteristics. property resale value and complete lifecycle expenses. Let’s dive into both options to uncover the advantages and disadvantages to both popular roofing systems.
________________________________________
What Are Asphalt Shingles?
The roofing market in North America primarily uses asphalt shingles because they offer an economical solution and simple installation.
What are the 3 Types of Asphalt Shingles
- 3-Tab Shingles – Flat, thin, single layer. Lightweight and budget-friendly
- Architectural Shingles – Multi-layer, Dimensional. Higher wind resistance
- Premium Designer Shingles – Class 4 Rated Fire Resistant, Thicker, More Durable.
There are three types of asphalt shingles. The traditional 3 tab, the popular architectural, and the thicker premium or designer shingles.
The layered structure of Architectural Shingles produces a thicker design that enhances their durability.
Luxury Designer Shingles are even thicker and are hail impact resistant. They present a design which duplicates the appearance of natural slate or cedar shake roofing materials.
Common Applications
Residential homes benefit best from this material choice when located in climates that experience moderate weather conditions. The majority of homes in the South – specifically Nashville, TN, will have an asphalt shingle roofing system installed.
What is Metal Roofing?
The modern roofing alternative to traditional shingles exists in the form of metal roofing materials including aluminum, steel and copper.
Types of Metal Roofing
- Standing Seam Panels
- Corrugated Metal Sheets
- Metal Shingles
Common Applications
Both commercial buildings and upscale residential buildings adopt metal roofing as their material of choice for locations with extreme weather conditions.
________________________________________
Durability Comparison
The lifespan of metal roofing products exceeds asphalt shingles because metal roofs last 40–100 years while asphalt shingles reach their end at 15–30 years (some manufacturers warranty the material up to 50 years) The “buy it once” investment advantage belongs to metal roofing.
Feature Asphalt Shingles Metal Roofing Lifespan 15–30 years 40–70+ years Impact Resistance Moderate High |
Cost and Affordability - Which Roof is Best?
Cost is often a major deciding factor when facing a roof replacement. Determining which type of roofing is best for your home can be a daunting task.
The installation cost of asphalt shingles ranges between $3.50 and $7.50 per square foot.
Metal Roofing averages $7.00–$16.00 per square foot (installed)
Asphalt shingles have a lower initial cost, while metal roofing offers long-term savings due to its longer lifespan and enhanced energy efficiency. For homeowner’s planning to remain in their home for a long period of time, the ROI for a quality metal roof is a good investment.
________________________________________
Aesthetic Appeal and Design Flexibility
The market offers asphalt shingles in diverse color options combined with multiple texturing choices such as the GAF Slateline which was created to mimic the look of a slate roof. These roofing materials work well for every home design. Metal roofing now provides modern-style panels and traditional shingle designs that bring forth a contemporary aesthetic.
Architectural shingles provide an affordable luxury roofing look while metal roofs, especially standing seam panels, establish a more modern aesthetic look.
________________________________________
Installation Complexity
Asphalt shingles are much easier to install and can be installed much faster than a metal roof. Since it is easier to train roofers to install shingle roofs, there are more roofers who specialize in asphalt shingle installation. This makes the labor cost more affordable for asphalt roofing.
The installation process for metal roofing demands specific equipment along with advanced skills which causes installation expenses to increase and increases the construction time. Naturally, this causes the labor cost more expensive for metal roofing.
________________________________________
Energy Efficiency and Insulation
Metal roofs are energy efficient because they reflect heat up and away from your home. The reflective surface on metal roofs helps reduce cooling expenses by 10–25%.
The reflective granules found in certain asphalt shingles provide limited efficiency compared to the raw efficiency of metal roofs.
Pro Tip: Add a cool-metal coating for even better energy performance.
Is Metal Roofing Weather Resistant?
Yes! Metal roofing holds up well against Mother Nature! This is why many insurance companies offer a discount off homeowner’s premiums for homes that have metal roofing. The material holds up better than asphalt shingles under conditions of heavy snowfall and hail and rain exposure. Ice dams are also reduced because snow and ice are more likely to slide off of a metal roof.
The freezing temperatures cause asphalt shingles to lose their flexibility which eventually leads to cracking.
________________________________________
Maintenance Requirements
Having a roof inspection of asphalt shingle roofs is a necessity after storms. Once a roof has reached 10 years of age, annual inspections are highly recommended to prevent small issues from becoming major problems. Homeowners need to perform shingle replacements or repair them at regular intervals starting around the 10 year mark for a 3-tab roof.
Metal roofing? Virtually maintenance-free. Regular inspections combined with periodic removal of debris constitute the maintenance requirements.
________________________________________
What is the Environmental Impact of Roofing?
The disposal of asphalt shingles ends up as a major contributor to landfill waste.
Metal roofs exist as 100% recyclable materials after their service life.
Metal roofs receive a double environmental benefit because they contain recycled materials during their initial production process.
________________________________________
Fire Resistance and Safety
Metal roofing materials provide Class A fire resistance because they resist combustion while also being non-flammable materials. Metal roofs obtain automatic Class A fire resistance while asphalt shingles have Class A ratings available as optional features.
________________________________________
Resale Value and ROI
Remodeling Magazine indicates that metal roofs generate 60–85% of their installation costs during home resale while asphalt shingles produce around 60% recovery.
The modern housing market shows increased demand for metal roofs because of their durability and fashionable design.
Regional Suitability
- Hot & sunny climates: Metal reflects heat—excellent in the South or desert areas.
- Cold & snowy climates: Snow slides off metal, reducing roof load.
- Storm-prone zones: Metal resists high winds better than shingles.
________________________________________
Common Myths and Misconceptions on Roofing
- “Metal roofs are noisy.” Not true. With proper insulation, they’re as quiet as shingles.
- “Shingles are outdated.” Modern architectural shingles offer high-end aesthetics.
- “Metal roofs attract lightning.” Also false. They don’t attract but safely conduct energy.
________________________________________
Real-Life Case Studies
Case Study #1: Nashville Homeowner
After sustaining storm damage, the homeowner decided to change to metal roofing from asphalt shingles. They reported that they received a discount on their insurance premiums and noticed improved cooling in their home during the hot and humid summer months which are normal for Nashville.
________________________________________
Expert Roofing Recommendations
If your budget is limited and you plan to live in the house for less than 15 years, asphalt shingles remain the best option for you. They will provide durable protection with an attractive appearance.
If you are staying in your home longer than 15 years consider metal roofing. Select metal for long-lasting durability, modern appearance, minimal upkeep along with energy-efficient benefits.
❓ FAQs
Metal roofing or asphalt shingles – which option costs less?
The initial price of asphalt shingles remains lower than metal roofing systems. Metal roofing systems are more expensive during installation yet they extend their lifespan for multiple decades and need minimal upkeep.
Does metal roofing outlive asphalt shingles?
Metal roofing systems can endure for 40–100 years while asphalt shingle lifespan reaches between 15–30 years based on both product quality and weather conditions.
Is metal roofing noisier?
Nope! Metal roofs with correct installation show the same level of noise as shingle roofs especially when properly insulated.
Can you install metal roofing over shingles?
Yes, in many cases. A “roof-over” installation is possible when installing metal of shingles. However, removing old roofing down to the decking is always the best option! Always check with your local building codes to confirm what is required in your specific location.
What is the best roof for hot climates?
Metal roofing. The reflective surface of metal roofs creates significant indoor temperature reductions.
Which roof is easier to maintain?
Metal roofing wins here. The material resists mold growth and mildew while needing fewer repairs during its operational life.
________________________________________
✅ Conclusion – Metal Roofing vs Shingle Roofing
The decision between asphalt shingles and metal roofing needs to be made based on individual needs since each option serves different purposes. Your budget together with local weather conditions, design of your home, and future objectives will determine your choice. Metal roofing can provide a better long-term value over asphalt shingles despite asphalt being less expensive upfront. But, if you’re looking for a unique charm such as the look of slate roofing, then premium designer asphalt shingles will be your best option!
Select a reliable roofing contractor to work with after determining the climate and energy requirements specific to your area. MidSouth Construction is a local Nashville roofing company that specialized in all types of roofing. For more information on How Much Does A Roof Cost in 2025 or Warning Signs That It May Be Time To Replace your Roof – check out our blogs!
RECOMMENDED READS:
Table of Contents
Relevant Articles
Common Roofing Problems and Expert Solutions
Share at: ChatGPT Perplexity WhatsApp LinkedIn X Grok Google AI Common Roofing Problems & Solutions from Nashville Roofing Experts Roofing problems can be a homeowner’s worst nightmare – especially in Middle Tennessee’s unpredictable climate. If issues aren’t caught early, small problems can lead to significant damage. In this article, we’ll explore common roofing issues and how professional roofing contractors, including
Reasons Why Regular Roof Maintenance is Essential for Your Home
Share at: ChatGPT Perplexity WhatsApp LinkedIn X Grok Google AI The Importance of Regular Roof Maintenance Your roof is one of the most important structural protections your home has. It shields your property from the elements, protects the interior from water damage, and preserves the overall integrity of your house. At Roofing by MidSouth, we help homeowners throughout Nashville understand
The Characteristics of Upscale Roofing Materials: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Specialty
Share at: ChatGPT Perplexity WhatsApp LinkedIn X Grok Google AI The Characteristics of Upscale Roofing Materials – A Complete Guide for Homeowners Homeowners choose upscale roofing materials because these products deliver superior looks, extended durability, and excellent performance. The Nashville roofing experts at MidSouth Construction deliver elite roofing and restoration services to Middle Tennessee residents. Our company operates as a